General Overview ......A large, strong Tosai with very good balance. The fish swim powerfully and the sequential of strokes are rhythmic and correct. This fish have potential for further developement. The slight roach on the back and the deep tail seating need further consideration.
Critiques are very important for the advancement of ranchus. One must learn to critique ranchu and not criticize ranchu. Last Year All Japan Ranchu Show yielded a very exciting and beautiful group of Tosai winners. I like to share how sometime with a bit of imagination and passion and in my little sketch book, I try expressing in words my feeling about the ranchu that I am viewing. Please note ..it is just my imagination running a bit wild and it is also something I like to do in my free time...it is just my little expression. Also please note... I may be wrong in my critique and as I always maintain... "I am just a student of ranchu".
The video clip of the swimming was taken from this youtube video posted by a Japanese hobbyist....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ch7wEBQAZR0&feature=channel_video_title
Footnote: Tosai wide, Tosai pronounced etc etc are just terms which I feel is the maximum that the fish as a Tosai can have...like some seniors ever mentioned...a Tosai should look like a Tosai...basically let say a Tosai have a headgrowth like an oya...then as it gets older...there isn't much room for further developement.
Hi Richard,
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your thoughts with so much creativity. Just one question and want to ask the last part why did you mentioned "need further consideration
William
Hi William,
ReplyDeleteI think a better video of that Tosai can be found in here....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=niaueKtG3s0
Coming from a dog background...I reckon a deep sitting tail seat is synomous to an "over angulated" dog hind quarter. An over angulated hindquater need a very strong, broad thigh and a good firm hock to create the power/energy to drive the movement forward. If the dog don't have a strong thigh and if the hocks are weak, the power from the rear will make the movement very wobbling.
Transposing it to my opinion of this beautiful tosai...the tail seat is deep...the back is strong and the peduncle is thick thus enabling the fish to swim with much power and grace....if the developement of this young fish is not managed properly(I doubt the Japanese Master will allow such a prized specimen to deteriorate) and thus the back weakened and the peduncle did not grow in proportion with the body and tail...the swimming will not be the same. IMHO it will be erratic and that is why I opinioned "need further consideration".
A very good example is my tosai listed below with a beautiful tail, but it don't have the strong back and broad peduncle to give the fish the power to swim beautifully....the swimming is erratic and like one good American friend commented...my fish swim like a snake lol!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Go3dcYnoVGQ
Please note...my fish quality is far inferior from the quality of that tosai and is for a negative illustration of the swimming.
Hope that help reflect my thoughts in ranchu language.
Best Regards
Richard
Hi Richard
ReplyDeleteThanks a million for making the effort to reply Cheers and get well soon.
William